The Cost of Corrosion and the Advantages of Composite Wrap Pipe Repairs over Conventional Steel Repair Techniques

April 30, 2025

Introduction

Pipelines and pipework are widely utilised in Heavy Industry for production, transportation and refining of liquids and gases.

To highlight the difference between pipelines and pipework, definitions of each have been put below.

  • Pipeline – A pipe with components subject to the same design conditions used to transport fluid between plants.
  • Pipework – Interconnected piping subject to the same set or sets of design conditions.

As of 2014, there were more than 2 million miles of pipelines in 120 countries around the world (Central Intelligence Agency, 2013).This figure doesn’t include pipework.

These pipelines and pipework are subject to deterioration and therefore present a huge maintenance challenge to the companies andgovernment agencies who operate them.

The cause of significant incidents to Oil & Gas transmission pipelines have been listed below (Reza Pourazizi, 2020).

  • Corrosion.
  • Incorrect operation.
  • Material/Weld/Equipment failure.
  • Natural force damage.
  • Other outside force damage.
  • All other causes.

The proportion of significant incidents that each of these causes could be attributed to are shown in Figure 1 below. This graphic shows that 63% of significant Oil & Gas transmission incidents have been as a result of corrosion.  

Figure 1 - Causes of significant oil and gas transmission pipeline incidents.

If left unmanaged, corrosion will result in pipelines and pipework being put out of service due to premature failure, leakage or forced shutdown (W. S. Sum, 2016). The global cost of corrosion was estimated in 2016 to be USD$2.5 trillion, equivalent to 3.4% of global GDP in 2013 (Koch, 2017). In the USA in 2007, the average annual corrosion related cost of monitoring, replacing and maintaining gas and liquid transmission pipelines was USD$7billion. Of this USD$7 billion, 80% was attributable to the maintenance and operation of corrosion related problems (United States Department of Transport,2007). This percentage indicates that effectively managing corrosion of pipelines and pipework is the key challenge faced by heavy industry to operate more safely and cost effectively.

 

What’s the solution?

When identified, defects are assessed by the operator. Anassessment will then be made to establish whether a repair is necessary toensure that safe operation of the pipeline or pipework is continued. There are two main types of repair techniques available to pipeline and pipework operators (K.S. Lim, 2016). These have been listed below, and broken down into the specific repair systems.

Conventional steel repair techniques.

  • Like-for-like replacement.
  • Full-encirclement steel sleeve (Figure 2).
  • Steel repair clamp.

Figure 2 - Full-encirclement steel sleeve

Composite wrap systems.

  • Pre-cured layer system.
  • Flexible wet lay-up system.
  • Pre-impregnated system (Figure 3).

Figure 3 - Pre-impregnanted composite wrap pipe repair

Analysis comparing conventional steel repair techniques and composite overwrap systems shows that, on average, composite wrap systems are 24% cheaper than welded steel sleeve repairs and 73% cheaper than replacing the damaged section of the pipe completely (Koch, 2017). Further advantages of composite wrap repair systems over conventional steel repair techniques are listed below (W. S. Sum, 2016).

  • Greater corrosion resistance (W. S. Sum, 2016).
  • Weight savings, and therefore less loading on pipework (W. S. Sum, 2016).
  • Reduced lead time for repair completion (J.M. Duell, 2008).
  • Explosion potential eliminated as there are nohot-works (J.M. Duell, 2008).

Enter Icarus Composites

At Icarus Composites, our mission is to alleviate the burden of corrosion on Heavy Industry using Sustainable Composite Wraps.

We offer a comprehensive suite of goods and services centred around Engineered Composite Wraps for the repair and reinforcement of leaking and corroded pipelines. Composite wraps are versatile repair methods which allows Icarus Composites to offer a broad range of repair services.

  • Pipe integrity repair: Utilising ISO24817 and ASME PCC-2 compliant composite wraps to reinforce corroded, eroded, and damaged pipes, extending their lifespan by up to 20 years. These solutions are adaptable to various pipe materials like carbon steel, stainless steel, and CuNi, and can handle complex geometries and inaccessible locations.
  • Live leak sealing: Employing advanced techniques and skilled technicians to seal high-pressure, high-volume leaks without requiring operational shutdowns, maintaining system integrity and preventing costly downtime.
  • Subsea & Splash Zone repairs: Providing water-activated composite repair systems (like Oceanus 142) compliant with ASME PCC-2, specifically designed for the challenging conditions of underwater and splash zone environments.
  • Tank repairs: Offering ISO 24817 and ASME PCC-2 compliant composite repairs for tanks of all diameters and sizes, utilising specialised application methods for effective patch repairs.
  • Corrosion protection: Implementing a 20-year guaranteed corrosion protection system involving a coating and composite overlay to prevent oxygen, moisture, and other electrolytes from reaching the substrate.
  • Structural repairs: Composite wraps can be moulded to any geometry allowing the repair of complex structures such as I-Beams. Classical mechanics and FEA are used to design and apply composite wraps that restore structural components to their full design load-bearing capacity.
  • Technician training: Provide a comprehensive training programme covering composite wrap application and live leak sealing.
  • Engineering support: Our expert team ofengineers are available 24/7 to provide technical support and run detailed calculations in accordance with ISO 24817 & ASME PCC-2.

 

Why Icarus Composites & Composite Wraps?

Repairing pipes using Composite Wraps has a number ofadvantages over using Conventional Steel Repair techniques such as steel sleeves, steel repair clamps and like-for-like replacement.

  • Corrosion resistance: Unlike steel,composite materials are inherently resistant to corrosion, preventing future degradation of the pipe.
  • Cost-effectiveness: Composite wrap repairsare up to 73% cheaper than steel repairs, primarily due to reduced material costs, less labour-intensive installation, and minimised downtime (Koch, 2017).
  • Faster installation: Composite wraps can be applied more quickly than steel repairs, reducing repair time and associated downtime.
  • Minimal downtime: Many composite repair solutions can be applied while the pipeline remains in operation, avoiding costly shutdowns.
  • Versatility: Composite wraps can be used on various pipe materials (carbon steel, stainless steel, CuNi, etc.) and complex geometries (bends, tees, valves, etc.), offering greater flexibility than rigid steel solutions.
  • High strength-to-weight ratio: Composites provide significant strength and structural reinforcement with less weight than steel, simplifying handling and installation and reducing loading on the pipe.
  • Conformability: Composite wraps can conform to irregular pipe surfaces and defects, ensuring a tight fit and effective load transfer.
  • Reduced need for hot works: Unlike welding required for steel repairs, composite application often doesn't involve hot work, enhancing safety and reducing fire hazards.
  • Long-term solutions: Composite repairs can provide a long service life, often extending the lifespan of the pipe formany years.
  • Less disruption: Composite repairs generally require less excavation and disruption to the surrounding environment compared to steel repairs.

At Icarus Composites, our personnel have years of experience designing and applying composite wraps, and sealing leaks live to prevent costly downtime. We deliver high-quality, ISO 24817 and ASME PCC-2 compliant composite wrap repairs, minimising downtime through efficient application and live leak sealing techniques. We have a strong focus on extending asset lifespan and a 24/7 support system, Icarus Composites ensures that companies receive tailored solutions and expert assistance, optimising operational efficiency and reducing long-term maintenance costs.

 

Interested in knowing more?

At Icarus Composites, we know your operations don’t stop. Our team is available 24/7 to ensure you have an expert on hand to contact. Please find our contact details below – we’d love to hear from you!

References

Central Intelligence Agency, 2013. The World Factbook: FieldListing - Pipelines. [Online] Available at: https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/pipelines/

J.M. Duell, J. W. M. K., 2008. Analysis of a carboncomposite overwrap pipeline repair system. International Journal of PressureVessels and Piping, 85(11), pp. 782-788.

Koch, G., 2017. Cost of corrosion. In: Trends in Oil and GasCorrosion Research and Technologies. s.l.:Woodhead Publishing, pp. 3-30.

K.S. Lim, S. A. N. N. N. Y., 2016. An Overview of CorrodedPipe Repair Techniques. International Journal of Chemical, Molecular, Nuclear,Materials and Metallurgical Engineering, 10(1).

Reza Pourazizi, M. M.-B. j. S., 2020. Investigation ofdifferent failure modes in oil and natural gas pipeline steels. EngineeringFailure Analysis, 109(104400).

United States Department of Transport, 2007. Corrosion costsand preventative strategies in the United States, s.l.: United StatesDepartment of Transport.

W. S. Sum, K. H. L. L. P. D. T. K. T. N. A. Y. L. L. &.P. F., 2016. Design, testing and field deployment of a composite clamp forpipeline repairs,. Plastics, Rubber and Composites, Volume 45:2, pp. 81-94.